Home / Your options compared
Options compared
Your options when you owe more than the house is worth
There are more than most owners expect. None is free of trade-offs, so here they are side by side, with the questions to ask about each.
Side by side
Use the table as a map, then read the details underneath. Every route has a cost, and the right one depends on your savings, your timeline and what the house is worth.
| Route | What it asks of you | Good fit when | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sell and bring cash to closing | Cash for the gap plus costs | You have savings or help and want to be done | Spending reserves you may need |
| Short sale | Lender approval, paperwork, patience | You cannot cover the gap and need out | Slow, uncertain, credit and tax questions |
| Wait | Keep paying the costs | You live there and can afford it | The market may not move |
| Rent it out | Become a landlord | Rent covers most of the payment | Repairs, vacancy and a harder sale later |
| Ask the lender for help | A call and documents | Payments are strained | Not every program fits every loan |
| Sell as it stands to a direct buyer | Accept a lower price for speed | Repairs or timing block a normal sale | Compare offers and read everything |
| Keep living there and cut costs | Budgeting and patience | You are not forced to move | Deferred maintenance |
The routes, in a little more detail
Bring cash to closing
If the sale price does not cover the payoff and costs, the gap is paid at the table. Run your own numbers with the net-proceeds math first so the figure is not a surprise.
Short sale
The lender agrees in writing to accept less than the full loan. Expect documents about your finances and a timeline measured in months. Ask a licensed attorney whether the lender could still pursue any remaining balance in your state, and ask a tax professional about forgiven debt.
Wait
Principal paydown and local prices can narrow a gap, but neither is guaranteed. Total the monthly costs on the stuck-house guide before you choose this route.

More routes worth knowing
Rent the house
Rent can carry the payment while you wait. It also makes you responsible for tenants, repairs and insurance, and it can complicate a later sale.
Ask the lender about hardship programs
Lenders sometimes offer repayment plans, loan changes or other help. Asking costs nothing. A HUD-approved housing counselor, found through HUD, can help you ask the right questions.
Sell as it stands to a direct buyer
Some buyers purchase houses without requiring repairs and close on your date. You usually trade price for certainty. We may be such a buyer and we say so. See selling when you cannot afford repairs for the full trade-off.
Keep the house and cut costs
Not every stuck owner has to sell. If you live there and can cover the payment, staying can be the cheapest answer.
How to choose
Start with the gap from the worksheet. Then ask three questions: how long can I afford to wait, how much cash can I truly spare, and what is the cost of each month of delay? Your answers narrow the table to two or three routes.

If you need a sounding board, the form below reaches a person, and the questions and answers page explains what the call looks like.
Before you act on any of it
Short sales, loan changes and debt forgiveness have legal, tax and credit consequences. Talk to a licensed attorney, a tax professional and a HUD-approved housing counselor before you commit. If your house is under an active exclusive listing agreement, let it end or involve your agent first. The article on what it means to owe more than your house is worth is a good companion read.
Tell us where you stand
Send a few details and a real person will call you back to talk it through. Bring whatever numbers you have, even rough ones. We will tell you plainly if selling is not the right move right now.
There is no obligation, and nobody will push you toward a decision you are not ready to make.
Talk it through
Free to ask. No obligation to do anything.